Design for The U.S. Senate

"Democracy entails not just volume rule, however rampart of minority rights," said L. capital of Minnesota Bremer III, Administrator, Coalition Provisional Authority in Iraq (Kimberely). He do this statement after giving a very starry-eyed yearend review to the American occupation of Iraq. The American allegiance to the protection of minority rights was an effort to prevent Iraq's Shiite majority from demanding i man, one vote, majority rule, and underlined a need to satisfy the Sunni and Kurd minorities. The irony of the talk is that the Republican's, while showing such concern for the rights of Iraqis, show no such concern for the rights of minorities at home in America. When Lani Guinier was nominative by President Clinton to service of process as Assistant attorney General for Civil Rights, she was called "loony" and a "quota queen" for advocating for the unite States exactly what Bremer advocated for Iraq. Ms. Guinier was not attempting to create a compliant putz government: she was merely trying to bring justice to the electoral system of the United States. Guinier was standing up for minority rights against majority rule.

More irony was seen when George Bush won the presidential choice in 2000, underlining the second-class status of out-voted minorities who voted for Al thrust. As Guinier noted, Gore voters,

Earlier this year, Senator Robert C Byrd warned the Senate and the American people about a procedural effort existence considered by some Senators to except off debate and shut down minority voices and opinions (U.S.). Byrd believes such an effort strikes at the inaugural Amendment right of set free speech. The Republicans are threatening to get free of the filibuster, a method of prolonging debate in the Senate to delay the applause of some judges who are put up for handicap by the administration.

This so-called "nuclear option" is said to be directed solely at the Senate's advice and consent prerogatives regarding federal judges, but the claim that no right exists to filibuster judges aims at the heart of the Senate's long tradition of unlimited debate.

Byrd maintained that free and open debate on the Senate floor ensures citizens a suppose in their government (U.S.). The American people are comprehend through their Senators. Byrd compared what the Republicans are trying to do in fillet the filibuster to what Hitler did to come to power by making the illegal legal. He says that what the nuclear option seeks to do with Rule twenty-two of the Standing Rules of the Senate is to alter the rules by sidestepping them, and making the impermissible the rule. To serve immediate partisan roles, the Republicans are prepared to risk violating the nation's encumbrance democratic values and poison the Senate's deliberative process.

U.S. Senator Robert C. Byrd. "Stopping a strike at the heart of the Senate." 1 Mar. 2005. 19 whitethorn 2005.

"Constitutional Democracy." Undated. 19 May 2005.

Order your essay at Orderessay and get a 100% original and high-quality custom paper within the required time frame.